Sponsored By
An organization or individual has paid for the creation of this work but did not approve or review it.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

10 years after a 22-year-old was killed in a murder-for-hire plot, the last of 5 defendants is sentenced

Jessica Rehfeld’s body was found in 2016 in rural South Dakota, one year after her boyfriend hired four men to carry out her murder and cover-up.

South Dakota Victim.jpg
Richard Hirth, 44, was sentenced Monday to life in prison for his role in the 2015 murder of 22-year-old Jessica Rehfeld. Hirth was the last of five men to receive sentencing in the murder-for-hire plot initiated by Rehfeld’s ex-boyfriend.
Contributed / Pennington County Attorney’s Office

RAPID CITY — The quest for justice in the heinous murder of a South Dakota woman a decade ago has come to a close.

Richard Hirth, 44, was sentenced to life Monday, July 7, for his involvement in a 2015 murder-for-hire plot, which resulted in the death of 22-year-old Jessica Rehfeld.

ADVERTISEMENT

Hirth, who fatally stabbed Rehfeld multiple times before burying her in a shallow grave, pleaded guilty Monday to abetting first-degree manslaughter. As part of the plea agreement, the first-degree murder charge was dropped.

Despite dropping the first-degree murder charge, Hirth’s conviction results in South Dakota’s maximum sentence for abetting first-degree manslaughter.

“Make no mistake, this was a calculated and cold-blooded killing,” Pennington County State’s Attorney Lara Roetzel said in a press release. “This plea allowed us to finally resolve this case, something Jessica’s family desperately needed. We were optimistic that even under the lesser charge, the Court would impose a life sentence, and we’re grateful that it did.”

Rehfeld’s family and friends have waited a decade to see Hirth, the last of five men involved in the murder-for-hire plot, convicted and sentenced.

Family members describe the 22-year-old as a strong and vibrant young woman who never stopped fighting.

“We will never forget Jessica’s courage in her final moments. She fought to live. She asked to speak to her father. She begged to see the stars. Her voice, even in her last breath, is what drives us to stand here today and affirm that her life mattered,” Roetzel said in the press release, describing the scene before Rehfeld’s murder.

South Dakota Victim Press Conference.jpg
Jessica Rehfeld was 22 years old when she was killed in South Dakota murder-for-hire plot initiated by her ex-boyfriend. After a decade, all five men involved have been sentenced for their involvement.
Photo courtesy of the Pennington County Attorney's Office

Rehfeld was first reported missing by family members and friends on May 22, 2015 — 10 days after filing a restraining order against Jonathon Klinetobe, her ex-boyfriend.

ADVERTISEMENT

She feared for her safety.

On May 18, 2015 — days after the restraining order was filed, and days before she was reported missing — Rehfeld was seen leaving the ex-boyfriend’s home in Rapid City with two men: Hirth and David Schneider.

The two had been recruited by Klinetobe to kill Rehfeld.

In exchange, Klinetobe agreed to pay the men $80,000. He falsely told them the payment would come from the Hells Angels, who had a bounty on his ex-girlfriend.

Rehfeld willingly left with the two men after they offered her a ride to work. Instead, they took her to a service road outside of Rapid City, , a Forum Communications property.

For 20 minutes, Rehfeld fought while Schneider restrained her and Hirth repeatedly stabbed her. Klinetobe helped the two men bury her body, according to a Pennington County press release.

Not long after her death, Klinetobe brought two other men into the plot.

ADVERTISEMENT

He hired Michael Fry and Garland Brown to dig up Rehfeld’s body — and take her to another location, where they buried her in a deeper grave near Rockerville.

Map Rapid City to Rockerville.PNG
In 2015, assailants involved in the murder 22-year-old Jessica Rehfeld transported her body from a shallow grave outside of Rapid City to a second grave in Rockerville.
Photo courtesy of Google Maps

Nearly one year later, a witness contacted authorities in Newcastle, Wyoming, with information about Rehfeld’s case.

The witness led investigators to an area outside of Rockerville, where they discovered Rehfeld’s body.

Brown was convicted that year — in 2016 — to five years in prison for his role as an accessory.

Klinetobe pleaded guilty in 2017 to aiding and abetting first-degree manslaughter, and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

In 2020, Schneider was sentenced to 75 years in prison for aiding and abetting first-degree manslaughter.

Frye pleaded guilty to accessory to first-degree murder and was sentenced to five years in prison.

ADVERTISEMENT

Hirth’s trial was initially scheduled for 2023, but was repeatedly delayed due to questioning of his defense team’s expert witnesses and concerns over his mental capacity to stand trial.

His sentencing marks the end of the 10-year quest for justice in Rehfeld’s murder.

Trisha Taurinskas is an enterprise crime reporter for Forum Communications Co., specializing in stories related to missing persons, unsolved crime and general intrigue. Her work is primarily featured on The Vault.

Trisha is also the host of The Vault podcast.

Trisha began her journalism career at Wisconsin Public Radio. She transitioned to print journalism in 2008, and has since covered local, national and international issues related to crime, politics, education and the environment.

Trisha can be reached at ttaurinskas@forumcomm.com.
Conversation

ADVERTISEMENT

What To Read Next
Get Local

ADVERTISEMENT