Sponsored By
An organization or individual has paid for the creation of this work but did not approve or review it.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

This hockey player paved the way for girls to play boys sports

In 1984, Carrie Preusse challenged the bylaw that had only allowed girls to play noncontact sports in North Dakota. Her efforts led to girls joining wrestling and football teams soon after.

Carrie_Preusse_photo copy.jpg
Fargo South JV hockey player Carrie Preusse skates at the Coliseum in Fargo during her first high school game as the Bruins took on Fargo Shanley on Friday, Dec. 21, 1984.
Nick Carlson / The Forum via newspapers.com

FARGO — Much like Becky Dooley, the first girl to play on a North Dakota high school boys baseball team in 1974, Carrie Preusse needed to put up a fight.

In 1984, Preusse was a sophomore at Fargo South. Already a cross country and track standout, hockey was her winter love. She began playing park board hockey in Fargo in second grade and eventually played for the Southside Flyers Bantam B team.

ADVERTISEMENT

It was her fight in 1984 that opened the doors in North Dakota for girls to play on boys teams.

Growing up on the outdoor rink at Clara Barton Elementary in Fargo, she’d also skate with her friends Kevin and Kim Wagner on their pond. One day at school, their father and South head hockey coach, Myron Wagner, stopped Preusse (rhymes with “choice”) and asked her if she was going to try out for the Bruins.

Eventually she said yes.

“Did I ever think I was going to be opening up a can of worms? No, I did not,” Preusse told the Sports Time Machine. “And for me, it was just being a female. I had played with a lot of these guys through the years on the park board, so I didn't think anything of it.”

But others did. The North Dakota High Activities Association did not yet allow girls to play in boys contact sports.

After Dooley, who was featured recently by the Sports Time Machine , the NDHSAA changed its bylaws to allow girls to play on noncontact boys teams. Baseball, hockey, football and other rougher sports were still off limits to girls.

Preusse said assistant principal Patricia Schroeder relayed the news.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I wasn't really happy about that,” Preusse recalled. “I said some really nice words and stomped out.”

Devastated, she talked to her father, Rick, later that day. Asking if she still wanted to play hockey, he then told his daughter, “OK, I’ve already contacted an attorney and here we go. We’ll fight ‘em for it. We’ll try to get you on the ice.”

Carrie_Preusse_lawsuit_11_15_84.jpg
A Nov. 15, 1984 article about Carrie Preusse that appeared in The Forum.
Newspapers.com

said Preusse could continue to practice with the JV team.

“I think a female should have an opportunity to try out for the hockey team,” Bennett said in 1984. “My personal feeling is that to prevent a female from a chance to show her skill is a denial of due process which, in my opinion, should be protected by ... our 14th Amendment. I look at it as more of a constitutional consideration, because to deny all females a chance to participate is a presumption of female inferiority.”

In the following days, the NDHSAA board was notified of the impending lawsuit.

In early December, the lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in Fargo. Preusse charged four defendants (the NDHSAA, Fargo Public s board of education, South principal Richard Warner and athletic director Harold Pedersen) with discrimination. She sought a temporary restraining order preventing the defendants from keeping her off the roster of the Fargo South JV team.

“I wasn’t trying to prove a point to the world,” Preusse recalled. “It was just like, ‘Hey, wait a minute. Why can’t I do this? I don’t understand this.”

ADVERTISEMENT

She understood the team’s coaches, which included junior varsity coach Curt Smith, could have simply cut her.

“I wasn’t one of the best players on the team,” Preusse said. “Fair enough, had they cut me, and they could have cut me because I wasn’t one of the top players, I would have held my head high and walked off that ice and back to the park board (league).”

A hearing, set for Dec. 20, was delayed until Jan. 21, 1985. In the meantime, Preusse continued to practice with the team.

At the time, the NDHSAA bylaw stated that members of both sexes may participate on the same teams in noncontact, noncollision sports. Until the day of her first game, it was assumed that the bylaw also meant members of both sexes were not allowed to partipate on the same teams in contact, collision sports like hockey, The Forum reported.

NDHSAA lawyers determined that the association had not interpreted the bylaw, thus no ruling had been made and there was no bylaw which specifically prohibited teams comprised of boys and girls in hockey. So Bennett ruled Pruesse could play and later urged the NDHSAA to change its rules.

This is the game story from Carrie Preusse's first game with the Fargo South JV hockey team in December 1984. Click on image for to read the full story on newspapers.com.

Preusse played her first JV game on Dec. 21 as the Bruins played Fargo Shanley at the Coliseum. She played about half-a-period’s worth during her shifts as winger on the third line, The Forum reported. While she didn’t score a goal or have an assist in South’s 6-2 win, she definitely drew a crowd and various media.

Shanley coach Dean Wilson didn’t tell his team they were going up against a girl skater. Recalling that game more than 40 years later, Wilson said, “I just wanted to play. I think that's a good call, because I remember I didn't want anybody to target her.”

ADVERTISEMENT

But in following games, players may have.

Once a player checked her into the boards, then apologized. In another game, a player came off the bench, skated across the ice and slammed her into the boards, spraining her wrist. He just skated away.

“There were some extremes,” Preusse said. “But coach would look out for my safety — fair enough — they didn’t want me getting hurt out there.”

Wilson said he understood Preusse’s fight. At times, the coach struggled with just having enough boys to fill Shanley’s roster.

“I remember I got hate mail, because I go, ‘I’d love to have all kinds of girls, if they're good players, I want them.’” recalled Wilson, the father of four daughters himself. “And I got letters. I mean, people are going, ‘You're an idiot. Girls can't play hockey, and blah, blah.’”

Carrie ndhsaa_decision_012985.jpg
A Jan. 29, 1985 article the North Dakota High Activies Association amending a bylaw that appeared in the Grand Forks Herald.
Newspapers.com

It was the only season of high school hockey Preusse would play. But it was her efforts that paved the way for girls to play on boys teams in North Dakota. Soon, Kim Rowland and Sue Johnson joined the West Fargo wrestling team and other girls joined football squads in Mandaree and Minot.

“At the time, back then, no,” she said about understanding her impact. But what about now? “Absolutely, and for a long time I’ve understood that.”

ADVERTISEMENT

After graduation, she moved to the Twin Cities and played hockey for the University of Minnesota women’s club hockey team and attended Minneapolis Community College. For one of her women’s studies courses, Preusse was assigned to give a speech on someone significant who made a change in the world.

Preusse UM.jpg
Carrie Preusse played for the University of Minnesota women's club hockey team after high school.
Contributed / Carrie Preusse

“I just said, ‘I’m going to do it on myself,’ because this is easy,” she said.

A classmate, who was also an arson investigator and knew her athletic background, encouraged her to try out for the Minneapolis Fire Department. Today, Pruesse is preparing to wrap up a 30-year career with the Minneapolis Fire Department where she’s been a captain since 2007. She continued to play hockey with several Division A teams and also operates , an electrotherapy business, with her sister Suzanne Wheeler.

Wilson recalls ice time was difficult to get for girls in the years following years. Some arena workers weren’t always willing to clean the ice for their practices, he said, and practice times were less than ideal.

It would take 18 years after Preusse played that first game before girls hockey, in 2002, became a sanctioned high school sport in North Dakota. Minnesota launched girls hockey in 1994.

Rob Beer is the sports editor for The Forum of Fargo-Moorhead. He's been a journalist with Forum Communications since 1991. He can be reached at rbeer@forumcomm.com.
Conversation

ADVERTISEMENT

What To Read Next
Get Local

ADVERTISEMENT